The Science of Mattering: How Jennifer Breheny Wallace is Redefining Well-Being and Self-Worth

Leave a Comment / Oprah Winfrey
The Science of Mattering: How Jennifer Breheny Wallace is Redefining Well-Being and Self-Worth

In a world where social comparisons are never more than a swipe away and societal expectations weigh as heavily as ever, understanding our true value can feel elusive. But what if the key to our emotional health, meaningful relationships, and personal success lies in something far more essential—and yet often overlooked? Enter Jennifer Breheny Wallace, the award-winning journalist and bestselling author, whose latest discussion with Oprah Winfrey on The Oprah Podcast puts a name to this elusive force: “mattering.” In their deep and insightful conversation, they unpack why feeling like we matter isn’t just a nice-to-have—it’s a biological necessity.

Jennifer’s new book, at the heart of this powerful podcast episode, explores the transformative concept of mattering, embedding it within both scientific research and human experience. If you’ve ever questioned your significance, felt unseen, or wondered about the hidden toll of pressure and disconnection, this conversation—and the ideas it brings to light—offers more than comfort. It delivers empowerment.

Welcome to a transformative dive into why we matter, how we can cultivate this feeling of significance, and what Jennifer Breheny Wallace’s groundbreaking work means for you, your loved ones, and society as a whole.

Table of Contents

1. What is Mattering? A Definition That Resonates

At its core, mattering is the feeling that we are significant to others and that our existence makes a difference. While this might sound philosophical, Jennifer Breheny Wallace sets the record straight: mattering is not abstract—it’s crucial.

In psychological terms, mattering involves three core components:

  • Feeling noticed by others
  • Feeling needed
  • Feeling appreciated or valued

This trio creates a sturdy psychological foundation that helps individuals build resilience, confidence, and purpose.

Jennifer emphasizes that mattering doesn’t require grand achievements. It doesn’t depend on accolades or Instagram likes. Instead, it’s rooted in relationships and communities where we feel seen and appreciated. And it’s something we can all nurture—both in ourselves and others.

2. The Origins of Jennifer’s Work: Journalism Meets Psychological Inquiry

Jennifer Breheny Wallace didn’t stumble upon the concept of mattering overnight. Her background as a journalist for renowned publications like The Wall Street Journal and The Washington Post honed her ability to ask probing questions—but it was her role as a parent that deepened her inquiry.

Concerned about the rising anxiety and pressure she saw in her own children—and in households across the United States—Jennifer began talking to psychologists, neuroscientists, educators, and parents. The common thread in all their findings? Mattering.

Her journalistic rigor combined with personal passion led to in-depth research, interviews, and eventually, her poignant new book. The result is a compelling case that mattering is not a luxury—it’s a human requirement.

3. Mattering vs. Self-Esteem: Understanding the Difference

It’s easy to confuse mattering with self-esteem, but Jennifer is quick to point out their differences.

  • Self-esteem refers to how we see ourselves.
  • Mattering refers to how we believe others see us.

While one is self-generated and often internal, the other is relational. You can have high self-esteem and still feel like your contributions don’t matter. Conversely, when you genuinely believe that you are critical to your family, friends, or community, your sense of self-worth naturally improves.

What Jennifer’s work helps illuminate is that chasing individual affirmation without social belonging or feedback can leave us hollow. Mattering is the missing ingredient in many personal development plans.

4. The Neuroscience Behind Mattering

Can something as subtle as “feeling seen” change your brain chemistry? As it turns out, yes. Mattering correlates with brain rewards similar to those generated by physical safety, nutrition, and affection.

In her research, Jennifer cites studies showing that when individuals feel valued by others, their brain’s prefrontal cortex lights up in ways associated with reduced stress and increased cognitive control. This neurological backing suggests that the effects of mattering are as real and vital as those of sleep or exercise.

Furthermore, the absence of mattering—feelings of invisibility or rejection—activates the same areas of the brain as physical pain. This highlights something profound: our need for human significance is not a cultural artifact. It’s hardwired.

5. How Mattering Impacts Mental Health and Well-Being

In her conversation with Oprah, Jennifer walks through the mental health implications of mattering—or the lack thereof. Adolescents who feel they matter are less likely to experience depression, anxiety, or engage in self-destructive behaviors. Adults with high levels of perceived mattering report greater life satisfaction, lower stress, and higher motivation.

By contrast, populations that feel marginalized or undervalued—whether due to workplace dynamics, sociocultural factors, or personal relationships—face higher rates of mental health challenges.

Mattering acts as both a shield and a motivator. It helps individuals weather life’s storms and gives them the energy and purpose to thrive.

6. The Cultural Crisis of Worthiness

Jennifer identifies a troubling trend: a cultural overemphasis on performance and perfection at the expense of intrinsic worth. In affluent communities especially, children are taught—implicitly or explicitly—that love and security are tied to achievement.

This mindset can erode the sense of mattering. Instead of feeling unconditionally valued, many feel they must continually earn their worthiness. Jennifer doesn’t place blame but rather calls for a cultural reevaluation of values. Her message is clear: “You do not need to perform to be worthy.”

7. Parenting for Mattering: Raising Kids Who Feel Valued

One of the most actionable takeaways from Jennifer’s work is how parenting styles can enhance—or diminish—a child’s sense of mattering. Here are a few tips from her research:

  • Listen without fixing: When children share their problems, listening attentively without rushing to solve shows that their emotions and perspectives matter.
  • Celebrate presence, not performance: Express pride in who they are, not just what they do.
  • Foster interdependence: Cultivate environments where kids can contribute meaningfully at home or in their communities, reinforcing that they have a role that matters.

According to Jennifer, helping your child feel like they matter may be the most powerful form of emotional armor you can give them.

8. Mattering in Schools and Institutions

It’s not just families that play a role. Schools and organizations must also cultivate environments where everyone, especially students and marginalized individuals, feels seen and essential.

Jennifer advocates for small, meaningful changes: teachers remembering students’ names, diverse representation in curriculum, peer mentorship programs—all of which reinforce the message, “You are not invisible.”

Educational systems that foster mattering see reduced drop-out rates, improved academic performance, and healthier student behaviors. The return on investment is both moral and measurable.

9. How Workplaces Can Foster a Sense of Significance

The workplace is another arena where mattering can make or break morale. Employees who feel their work is noticed and appreciated are more engaged, productive, and loyal. Conversely, those who feel devalued or replaceable are more likely to suffer burnout or leave.

Jennifer’s research suggests that leaders can do the following to reinforce mattering:

  • Offer specific, genuine praise
  • Provide clear paths for contribution and feedback
  • Create two-way communication channels
  • Recognize unseen labor (emotional or administrative work)

Mattering isn’t about flattery—it’s about validation.

10. Practicing Mattering Daily: Personal Strategies You Can Use

So how can you embrace mattering in everyday life? Jennifer outlines practical strategies anyone can adopt:

  • Express appreciation freely: Acknowledge the small contributions others make.
  • Ask meaningful questions: Go beyond surface-level talk to show people you truly care.
  • Engage in active reflection: Journal about who you matter to and why to reinforce internal beliefs.
  • Practice gratitude: Acknowledging who and what makes you feel valued helps nurture those connections.

The more we make mattering a conscious practice, the more reflexive it becomes in our social lives.

11. Oprah and Jennifer: Insights from the Podcast

The dynamic between Oprah Winfrey and Jennifer Breheny Wallace in their podcast episode underscores the urgency and relevance of mattering. Oprah, no stranger to exploring personal depth and societal change, contributes her own insights on how individuals can reclaim control over their narrative and redefine their purpose.

The synergy between host and guest is potent. Listening to the episode offers not just educational takeaways but emotional resonance—a reminder that even the most successful journey starts with the question: “Do I matter?”

12. Why This Conversation Matters More Than Ever

We live in paradoxical times—technologically connected yet emotionally starved. Rates of loneliness, burnout, and anxiety are higher than ever. Data may flood our screens, but real affirmation—real mattering—remains scarce.

Jennifer Breheny Wallace’s work rings like a clarion call: You matter. Not because of your résumé or your follower count, but because you exist within a web of relationships, hopes, and shared humanity.

This is not just a feel-good message. It’s an evidence-backed framework for navigating life with resilience and generosity.

13. Conclusion: Mattering as a Lifelong Compass

Jennifer Breheny Wallace has done more than spotlight an overlooked concept—she’s given us a roadmap. Understanding and fostering mattering can transform families, workplaces, schools, and communities. It invites us to recalibrate our focus from what we do to how we belong.

In a world clamoring for validation, the knowledge that we inherently matter might just be the most liberating truth of all.

So, the next time you ask yourself, “Do I make a difference?”—remember Jennifer’s work. Not only do you matter, but your recognition of someone else’s significance might just be the beginning of theirs.

Listen to the full discussion with Oprah to uncover even more insights—and embark on your own journey toward feeling valued, needed, and truly seen.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *